The Butler

It's not an interpretation of actual history as much as it is a reduced revision of movie history.

The Butler proves a decent, significant, but slightly stodgy affair. Its dignified restraint stifles its anger.

Amusing stunt casting aside, it's riveting to observe how civil rights evolved from inside the Oval Office

A high-minded, didactic, but irresistible entertainment ...

Forest Whitaker imbues his part with immense dignity and the old-age makeup is effective showcasing Cecil during his later years.

[A] turbulent, emotionally overpowering movie.

The Butler's final notes have too strongly followed through on traditional, slightly staid dramatics to have it both ways.

Is anyone else in America making films like Lee Daniels? For my money, he deserves his name above the title.

The breadth of the subject matter tirelessly works against director Lee Daniels and company, leading to some inevitably goofy casting choices and unfortunate make-up work.

The excitement comes from watching the director's rude energy chafe up against the constraints of a traditional Oscar-bait biopic.

The Butler is often impressively acted, beautifully shot and clearly designed to try to pick up a heartfelt award or two. But, as a film, it's too fragmented to carry its own weight on its shoulders and is over- burdened by a starry cast.

The Butler tells an obviously important and inspiring story, but the actual movie is laughable.